The budget benchmark of this ranking, and one Firsthand earns no commission on. Cheap, single-ingredient, and USP verified, with the standard caveat that melatonin helps circadian problems far more than routine insomnia.
Read the review →
A single-ingredient chelated magnesium at an honest dose and price. It carries the strongest human sleep evidence of the non-melatonin picks, but that evidence is concentrated in older and deficient adults, and the brand pushes auto-ship at checkout.
Read the review →
A no-frills, single-ingredient glycine powder that hits the exact 3 g dose used in the sleep studies for about $0.11 a serving. The evidence base is small but mechanistically interesting, and it is one of two picks here we earn nothing on.
Read the review →
A cleanly dosed 200 mg Suntheanine L-theanine softgel that is third-party tested and non-sedating. It targets the anxious, wired-before-bed state rather than sleep directly, and the supporting sleep evidence is a single small RCT.
Read the review →
A popular, palatable combination gummy with disclosed melatonin and L-theanine doses but token botanical amounts. It is the priciest and least evidence-backed pick, and gummies are the format most prone to dose inaccuracy.
Read the review →